Thanks for the guide. I've been trying to figure out why people keep suggesting Ifrit's Harpoon over the GC one – particularly the Twin Adder version, since the Serpent Lieutenant's Spear has a higher DPS rating and the always appealing Critical Hit Rating +25 (at the sacrifice of 3 STR and 1 Physical Damage on the Ifrit's Harpoon). Well, I actually typed up a post asking why and ended up doing some math while writing it, which I think answered my own question… so I'll share in case anyone else was also wondering (and to hopefully get confirmation).
Per this extremely verbose and intricate DRG thread, the stat weights are as such:
Weapon Damage: 10.541
Strength: 1
Crit: .222
Determination: .193
Skill Speed: .191
So let's compare that 3 STR you lose on GC weapon with the 25 Crit you gain:
25 * .222 = 5.55
which means the 25 crit is equal to 5 STR which means the GC weapon beats it on that stat.
However, using the same formula for that 1 Physical Damage, if I am understanding correctly:
1 * 10.541 = 10.541
Meaning that the mere 1 Physical Damage boost is worth 10 points of STR! Is that really right? That's crazy if so, but then I think I understand in that case. Because the two different formulas cross to form an end result of the Ifrit's Harpoon having what amounts to 5 STR more than the GC spear (actual STR as depicted on the weapon aside).
Did I understand correctly? :)
Lastly, if I may, I'd like to also link to this other one I also found and bookmarked:
I'm 50, Now What?
FoMante Officer replied
616 weeks ago